Legal Literacy - Imagine you are scrutinizing the article on murder in our criminal law, but suddenly you realize there is something odd: the word "intentionally" disappears from it. Is this a fatal legal blunder, or a brilliant doctrinal revolution? To the layman's eye, this new formulation may seem like a dangerous simplification, but for legal enthusiasts, this is a fundamental shift that changes the way we understand crime and punishment.
Welcome to the new era of Indonesian criminal law. Through Law Number 1 of 2023, or what is familiarly called the National Criminal Code, we are witnessing a major shift from the "old ways" inherited from the Dutch towards a more systematic system, but at the same time it holds traps for those who only read the law on the surface.
Shift from Monistic to Dualistic
The most radical change in the National Criminal Code is the transition from the doctrine of Monistic to the doctrine of DualisticIn the old Criminal Code inherited from the Netherlands, we are familiar with the monistic doctrine that unites criminal acts and criminal responsibility in one breath. This means that the elements of physical action and the perpetrator's inner intent are intertwined in every article.
However, the National Criminal Code chooses a different path. The drafters of the law adopted the dualistic doctrine in the academic sphere, which explicitly…
Comments
0Share your perspective politely, stay relevant, and focus on the article. Comments appear after moderation.
Join the discussion
Write a clear, polite response that stays on topic.
No comments yet. Be the first to discuss.
Comments will appear after moderation.